A veteran of 14 MLB seasons, Carpenter was open to persevering with his profession in 2025 as just lately as this previous September. That was following a season with the Cardinals the place he battled accidents and struck out at a 32.5 % clip however nonetheless produced a roughly common 95 wRC+ throughout 157 plate appearances in a part-time function. That type of manufacturing was sufficient to make Carpenter a stable bench piece, although with the Cardinals’ pivot towards offering younger gamers extra alternatives this 12 months, a reunion between the 39-year-old and his longtime membership wasn’t within the playing cards.
As Carpenter talked about, he was carrying Cardinal pink for many of his profession. The Playing cards chosen him within the thirteenth spherical of the 2009 draft. He made it to the large leagues in 2011, the 12 months of the membership’s most up-to-date World Collection win, however he was a footnote in that season. He was chosen to the roster in June and optioned again to the minors after a seven-game cup of espresso.
His main league profession started in earnest in 2012. As a 26-year-old rookie that 12 months, Carpenter took to hitting within the majors nearly straight away. He hit a powerful .294/.365/.463 in 114 video games whereas splitting time between first base, second base, third base, and each outfield corners. That present of versatility was sufficient to earn Carpenter a sixth-place end in Rookie of the 12 months voting even if he had but to generate the kind of energy he would later in his profession, clubbing simply six homers in 340 journeys to the plate. He additionally hit .286/.412/.571 in playoff video games, although the Playing cards have been felled by the Giants within the NLCS.
He took a step ahead in 2013 and had arguably his greatest season. He nearly doubled his energy output, attending to 11 residence runs. He walked at a ten % clip and solely struck out 13.7 % of the time. That led to a .318/.392/.481 slash and 146 wRC+. He was chosen to the All-Star group for the primary time. FanGraphs credit him with 7.2 wins above substitute for that season, his private greatest by a very good margin. He completed fourth in Nationwide League Most Priceless Participant voting. Carpenter didn’t carry out particularly nicely within the postseason that 12 months, hitting .217/.263/.290, however the Playing cards made it so far as the World Collection, shedding to the Crimson Sox in six video games.
The Playing cards then locked him up on an extension which might pay him $52M over the 2014 to 2019 seasons and maintain him in St. Louis into his mid-30s. Over the remainder of the last decade, his manufacturing shifted barely, with a bit extra energy however a bit much less on-base capability. The mixture was roughly comparable although, making him a really helpful participant as he bounced across the infield. From 2015-18, he hit between 21 and 36 residence runs in every season, totaling 108 lengthy balls in that four-year stretch. He slashed a mixed .260/.376/.497 for that span, resulting in a 135 wRC+.
In April of 2019, as Carpenter was coming into the ultimate assured 12 months of his deal, he and the Playing cards agreed to a different extension. This one would pay him $39M over the 2020 and 2021 seasons. Nonetheless, that in the end proved to be a misstep for the membership, as Carpenter’s manufacturing declined over these subsequent few years. His wRC+ completed at 96 in 2019, then 85 within the shortened 2020 marketing campaign, earlier than going all the way in which all the way down to 68 in 2021.
The Playing cards may have retained Carpenter for 2022 through an $18.5M membership possibility, however along with his declining outcomes, the $2M buyout was the simple name. That despatched him to free company for the primary time in his profession, forward of his age-36 season.
