2
Heading into the 2024-25 season, one Manchester United academy star tipped for a breakout marketing campaign was Toby Collyer.
Again in 2023, simply after United lifted the Carabao Cup, then-head coach Erik ten Hag was seen deep in dialog with Kobbie Mainoo.
Enter 2023–24: Mainoo, regardless of an early-season harm, went on to combat his manner into changing into a reliable first-team common.
His resurgence culminated in a Man of the Match show in United’s 2-1 FA Cup closing win over Manchester Metropolis, incomes him FA Cup Participant of the Season honours.
And so, following that success, it felt like déjà vu when, after that FA Cup closing, Ten Hag was once more seen chatting with Toby Collyer.
Social media buzzed with hypothesis. Was Ten Hag able to unearth one other gem? Was Collyer about to get pleasure from his personal “Mainoo season” in 2024-25?
Sadly, issues didn’t go as deliberate for the younger Purple Satan.
Collyer’s 2024-25 didn’t go to plan: Ten Hag sacking and accidents
United’s early struggles in 2024–25 held again his development. Ten Hag’s dismissal additionally didn’t assist his case.
With the Dutch tactician gone, any development plan laid out for the midfielder appeared to evaporate.
Though new head coach Ruben Amorim was anticipated to implement the midfielder’s development plan, that didn’t occur instantly.
Amorim’s process was to regular a faltering United aspect, and understandably, taking an opportunity on an unproven participant was not a high precedence.
To complicate issues additional, Collyer then endured two separate accidents (a leg harm adopted by a knock) that sidelined him for a lot of the second half of the season.
He did handle 12 senior appearances, together with a headline-grabbing debut in opposition to Liverpool and a goal-saving late cameo in opposition to Fulham, however there’s little doubt: 2024–25 was not his season.
So what now for Collyer?
United are set for a squad rebuild this summer season. New signings are anticipated, and a number of other names may make manner.
Collyer might not be a kind of to be moved on as he stays extremely regarded at Carrington — however is he really in Amorim’s plans?
He might be if the previous Sporting Lisbon boss is searching for his personal N’Golo Kanté.
“He may do two jobs in a single, and his ball retention was completely different class. You don’t get midfielders like him anymore,” former Liverpool Girls’s supervisor Matt Beard advised the MEN when requested a few workforce which may profit from Collyer’s companies.
“He was form of like (N’Golo) Kanté for Leicester. You want steadiness in a workforce. In case you had three Kobbie Mainoos, you may’t play all of them. You want a mix, and Toby will do stuff Mainoo gained’t. He’ll break the play up and get the ball to Mainoo.”
However it’s arduous to see Amorim viewing it the identical manner.
With strain mounting for United to return to their finest, workforce alternatives are sure to be vital.
Stories linking Middlesbrough midfielder Hayden Hackney with a transfer solely reinforce the sense that Collyer could discover it tough to interrupt into the primary workforce within the quick time period.
And with Amorim admitting lately that, with out European soccer, he doesn’t want a big squad, confirmed skills will probably be favoured over promising prospects.
One other season on the bench is not going to do for Collyer
For normal recreation time, a season-long mortgage with no obligation to purchase might be one of the best ways ahead.
One can solely hope Ten Hag is fast to take him to Bayer Leverkusen.
The Dutchman noticed potential in Collyer and would possibly know simply how one can unlock it. The familiarity, mixed with a transfer to a aspect that also employs a 3-4-2-1 system (if Ten Hag persists with it), might be excellent for the 21-year-old.
Collyer may thrive within the Bundesliga. Jadon Sancho and Jude Bellingham have already proven how effectively English skills adapt to German soccer.
A full season in a well-recognized system may assist Collyer rediscover rhythm, develop additional, and return able to tackle the Premier League.
If not, he may nonetheless be bought for a premium (like Bellingham and Sancho have been), funds that INEOS may reinvest to assist Amorim construct his ideally suited United squad.
Function picture Shaun Botterill through Getty Pictures
Observe us on Bluesky: @peoplesperson.bsky.social
