MAGNO'S BULGING MAIL SACK: CANELO-PBC, HANEY-GARCIA

So, was there some form of huge information that occurred this week? Apparently so. Let’s dig into my bulbous, bulging Mail Sack to search for some sanity in these weirdo occasions. This week, we discuss Canelo-PBC with a facet order of Devin Haney-Ryan Garcia.

Canelo vs. PBC

Hey Paul.

Canelo and PBC have parted methods. There are conflicting stories about what occurred, however there appears to be no going again now. What does this imply for Canelo, PBC and for the game of boxing normally? I’m at all times optimistic by nature, however you may’t spin Canelo vs. Berlanga and Benavidez vs. Not Canelo in a constructive means. What say you?

– John from RI

Hey John.

I received so many emails about this Canelo state of affairs that I’ll consolidate all of them into this response since you just about lined all of the bases.

The very first thing we now have to place out there may be that none of us– until we had been immediately a part of the dialogue– REALLY know the reality about this. There are media stories on the market, however you may’t take them as assured 100% non-biased and correct. We simply don’t know in relation to plenty of this.

In keeping with what’s been put on the market, though– largely by Dan Rafael and Jake Donovan– the break up occurred resulting from a disagreement over Canelo’s Might 4 opponent. In keeping with stories, Canelo wished Jermall Charlo for Might 4 and PBC, regardless of Charlo being wildly inactive, struggling via private points, and apparently inebriated the final time he was heard in public, was prepared to take the probably PPV loss on that battle, if Canelo would comply with face David Benavidez in September. That, apparently, is the place the deadlock was a bypass, resulting in the 2 sides parting methods. There’s additionally a report on the market that PBC had not put Benavidez on the listing of acceptable opponents from which Canelo may select when he first signed his three-fight cope with the corporate, thereby making it even simpler for Canelo to stroll away and probably declare breach of contract. If that final half is true, it was a serious tactical error by PBC, though the break up should still have occurred as a result of, by all accounts, Benavidez is completely not in Canelo’s rapid plans.

The Mexican star is seemingly intent on going again to DAZN the place he goals on exploring fights with Edgar Berlanga and Jaime Munguia.

However, once more, we don’t actually know and, not like everybody else, apparently, I’d really feel shaky about laying blame on both facet with out figuring out all of the information (I do know, ethics, wow!).

So…taking what we DO know, we now have a little bit of a foul state of affairs all-around.

No person needs to see Canelo vs. Edgar Berlanga– aside from Canelo, Berlanga, and the dependents of Canelo and Berlanga. Canelo vs. Munguia has the potential to be an entertaining motion battle, however Munguia is nowhere close to the identical stage as Canelo and the top result’s extra prone to be a one-sided boxing lesson en path to a late KO for Alvarez.

For PBC, a fast regroup and Plan B are so as. Their March 30 debut pay-per-view on Amazon Prime, headlined by the Tim Tszyu vs. Keith Thurman primary occasion, was regarded as a trial run to work out any kinks or complication on the brand new platform, earlier than going huge with Canelo on Might 4. It was additionally anticipated to be a revenue flatliner, business-acceptable as a prelude to the large Canelo battle. Clearly, that plan is out the window now. The corporate’s subsequent greatest attraction, Gervonta “Tank” Davis is reportedly tied to a bout with Frank Martin in the course of the summer season in some unspecified time in the future, though nothing’s been confirmed. Davis-Martin is an effective battle, however it gained’t carry the gross sales energy of a Canelo battle. Plus, that one’s not till the summer season, anyway (if it DOES occur). This places the corporate in a tricky spot, particularly contemplating the current losses and diminished market worth of PBC stars equivalent to Errol Spence, Deontay Wilder, and Jermell Charlo, who misplaced a one-sided choice to Canelo final September within the first (and apparently final) battle in his cope with the boxing firm.

We’ll see how all this shakes up, however not getting Canelo-Benavidez is a loss for boxing followers. And, a shaky begin to the PBC Amazon Prime deal, regardless of what the corporate’s serial critics dim-wittedly imagine, is dangerous for boxing as an entire.

In a glass half-full world, we’d have Terence Crawford re-signing with PBC for a bout with the winner of Tszyu-Thurman whereas Canelo fights Munguia first in Might. Then, perhaps, a Canelo-Benavidez cross-company bout in September, though this is perhaps nearer to science fiction than optimism. And whereas this is occurring, somebody, someplace builds Jaron “Boots” Ennis into the star he must change into as a result of we desperately want a brand new American star.

I’ll be writing extra concerning the Canelo state of affairs on this Monday’s Notes from the Boxing Underground column.

Devin Haney vs. Ryan Garcia

Hello Magno.

That Haney-Garcia NYC press convention was lit. Do you suppose this one goes to be a firefight or simply one other dud with plenty of pretend hate main into it?

– Tony

Hey Tony.

I wouldn’t name it a dud. I might say, although, that there’s nothing in Haney’s physique of labor that means a “firefight” is in his DNA. Having mentioned that, although, Ryan Garcia is so weak in so many ways in which he very nicely may get stopped. Haney can also be weak and it’s not out of the realm of risk that he might be clipped by Garcia’s rocket left hook which, in my not so humble opinion, remains to be certainly one of boxing’s greatest single-shot weapons. On the very least, there are some compelling points to this matchup, though I critical doubt {that a} conflict will erupt at any level. Almost definitely, we’ll see Haney competently and decisively outbox Garcia and the 2 will hug it out afterwards as a result of, “it’s all good.”

Acquired a query (or hate mail) for Magno’s Bulging Mail Sack? One of the best of one of the best will get included within the weekly mailbag section proper right here at FightHype. Ship your stuff right here: paulmagno@theboxingtribune.com.